Musical Chairs

November 18, 2026

Last fall, fashion played the biggest round of musical chairs anyone in the business can remember. Across one season of spring 2026 shows, 14 designers debuted at new houses. Matthieu Blazy moved from Bottega Veneta to Chanel. Jonathan Anderson moved from Loewe to Dior, putting men's, women's and couture under one designer there for the first time in decades. Demna left Balenciaga for Gucci, and Pierpaolo Piccioli took his seat at Balenciaga.

The logic was old and simple. Luxury was in a slump, and the industry's favorite fix for a slump is a new name on the door.

A year later, the quarterly numbers are in, and they make a useful case study for anyone who leads creative people, because the same move produced very different results.

Chanel looks like the clear winner so far. The house reported 2025 revenue of $19.3 billion, up 2 percent after a 4.3 percent fall the year before, and its executives credited the creative momentum around Blazy. The striking part is the timing, since his designs only reached stores in March 2026. Chanel said growth was running at a high single-digit pace early in the year, and by summer, first-half sales had accelerated into double digits.

Some of Chanel's turnaround arrived before a single new bag did, which tells you how much of a creative director's early value is belief.

Dior is improving inside a weaker group. LVMH's fashion and leather goods division fell 5 percent on an organic basis in the third quarter of 2026, mostly because of China. The company still singled out the success of Anderson's designs, with demand especially strong for ready-to-wear and leather goods, and over the summer Dior helped pull the division back into growth for the first time in two years.

Gucci is the slow one. Kering reported Gucci revenue of €1.29 billion for the third quarter, down 6 percent on a comparable basis. That's a real improvement on a year earlier, when the comparable decline was 14 percent, and nobody should mistake it for a recovery yet. Kering has closed 105 stores, net, across the group in the first nine months of the year, 25 of them Gucci's. The revival there is now one part creative direction and several parts real estate.

Then there's Versace. Dario Vitale showed one well-received collection in Milan in September 2025 and was gone by December, days after Prada Group completed its purchase of the house. He'd been hired by the previous owner.

One collection, eight months, a new landlord.

Four houses, four stories, and talent is the least interesting variable in all of them. Every one of these designers is gifted; that's how they got the job. What separated the outcomes was everything around them: how quickly new product could reach stores, how much of the business leaned on China, how many shops needed closing, and whether the person who hired you still owned the place.

Football (Soccer) has studied this question far more carefully than fashion has. Dutch economist Bas ter Weel and a colleague looked at clubs that sacked their manager mid-season. Results improved afterward, but they improved just as much at struggling clubs that kept their manager. Bad runs end on their own. The bounce is mostly regression to the mean, and later work by Jan van Ours at Erasmus University suggests clubs keep firing anyway because a new face is a visible response, a scapegoat with a press release.

Luxury has borrowed football's favorite fix. It should borrow football's data too.

Our own bias shows here. At a small studio (creators of Ding!) we talk constantly about Identity Architecture, the idea that a brand needs a system its people can read and build on. The two houses doing best right now gave their new designers a deep set of codes to work with. Blazy's early hits are reworked versions of Chanel's classic bags, shoes and tweed jackets. Anderson went back to Dior's New Look and put a bow on the Lady Dior. Both walked into a library and knew how to read it.

That's the lesson we'd carry out of luxury and into any studio, agency or in-house team. Hiring a brilliant creative leader is a bet on a person, and it pays off fastest when the house has codes worth inheriting.

There's a lesson for emerging creatives too, and it's less glamorous. Behind every name in the show notes is a studio of designers, pattern cutters and merchandisers whose names rarely make a press release. When the creative director changes, many of them stay and carry the house through the handover.

In a world of short contracts, be the person who knows where the codes live.

One year is early, and China makes every number noisier than usual. We'll check back next fall, expecting the winners to be the houses that hired a reader and handed over a good library.